Apr 02

Charles Dickens’ David Copperfield was first published in 1908*, and this quote is from that book:

Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen six,
result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure
twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.

-Wilkins Micawber in Charles Dickens’ novel David Copperfield

I don’t know if Dr Thomas Stanley, author of Stop Acting Rich, is aware of this quote, but after read his latest book, I suspect he’d agree wholeheartedly with the sentiment.

If you are looking for investment advice, this is not the book for you. Dr Stanley does not offer stock tips or advice on retirement planning. He has spent the better part of the last three decades studying the habits and writing about millionaires. His conclusion is that “most people will never earn enough money to become wealthy and to be hyperconsumers at the same time.” Stop Acting Rich offers examples of how the millionaires Dr Stanley observed lived, and teaches us how to make the distinction between the Income Statement Affluent (IA) and the Balance Sheet Affluent (BA). We see how it’s easy for a doctor earning $250,000/yr to live a lifestyle that has every dollar spent and maybe then some, yet a teacher or engineer whose family income may be ‘just’ in the mid-$100K but living beneath their means, managing to save their way to wealth.

Through the book we are shown brand examples, Timex vs Rolex for the choice of watches for instance. Real millionaires tend to not waste their money on the thousand dollar watches, preferring Seiko or Timex. As a fan of statistics and data, I appreciated the depth of analysis showing the correlation between real wealth and living the glittering rich life with no assets to show for it. In fact, it’s often tough to tell just by looks what someone’s balance sheet looks like. Most rich folk do not own vacation homes, boats, or planes. I recall an interview with Warren Buffet, who trades off year to year for the spot of richest man in the US. Mr Buffet was asked about boats, and he said that he had no interest in them, that when you’re Warren Buffet, you get invited on other people’s boats enough that you can avoid the hassle of maintaining one. He said that he was happy to spend time with his friends in his living room watching the 46 inch plasma TV and eating sandwiches. No champagne, no caviar.

A fair amount of writing is given to the discussion of Grey Goose Vodka and how its purchase correlates to glittering rich. Grey Goose buyers tend to drive prestige makes of cars, wear Rolex watches, drink other high end spirits, and spend more dining out. So as I was reading about this, I checked out my pantry (I don’t have a liquor cabinet) and sure enough, Grey Goose. Last I recalled, we had a bottle of Absolut or Smirnoff in there. I asked my wife if someone brought it over and she told me that the last time her sister was over she asked her what her preferred vodka was. Two thoughts came to mind as I heard this. First, for the bottle that will likely last over a year, $15 or $50 won’t ruin our budget. Second, given the details about how there’s little difference in vodka as it’s known for its lack of taste, my dear sister in law fell for the advertising pitch, and my dear wife, trying to make her sister feel welcome in our home, threw away an extra $20 or $30 to do so.

I enjoyed this book as much as I did prior books in Dr Stanley’s Millionaire series. It helped validate my own choices in cars (Toyota, built in the USA, by the way) watches (Timex) and other purchasing decisions that help keep my family on a path toward a stronger balance sheet. If you’d like to understand what the rich really buy, and wear, and where they go to eat, take some time and read this book, you’ll be surprised.

Joe

*Note: One of my faithful readers, Elle, alerted me that the date was 1850. Thanks Elle, I fact check my finance data a bit better than this. I promise.

written by Joe \\ tags: , , , , ,

10 Responses to “Stop Acting Rich”

  1. Elle Says:

    Friend JoeTaxpayer, David Copperfield was first published as a novel in 1850. Your date was suspect because I knew Dickens wrote _A Tale of Two Cities_, a fictional account of the period of the French Revolution. So he surely had to have been writing in the early-to-mid 1800s.

    I too am a fan of Dickens’s and Stanley’s efforts to help us appreciate what wealth is.

  2. Kristin - Certified Financial Planner Says:

    That is a fantastic title! I think that a lot of people are realizing the difference between wealth on paper and genuine affluence. I think that a lot our broader economic problems stem from the evolution of the word ‘millionaire’ from meaning someone that has $1,000,000 cash in the bank to someone whose assets are worth that much on paper. As we’ve seen, the bank won’t exchange your house for a giant pile of cash (anymore).

    Nice post!

  3. MoneyCone Says:

    I read somewhere that the rate of bankruptcy filing among lottery winners is higher than non lottery winners. These folks probably wouldn’t have filed for bankruptcy if they hadn’t won the lottery in the first place. Ironic isn’t it?

    When I was reading your review, I was thinking about a similar book ‘The millionaire next door’, then realized both the books are by the same author! Dr. Stanley’s common sense advice is priceless. Haven’t checked out this book yet, but plan to do so. Thanks for the review!

  4. Weekly Wisdom: Personal Economic Recovery » The Online Investing AI Blog Says:

    [...] Joe Taxpayer has some advice on saving money by not acting rich. [...]

  5. What is Cool Around the Web This Week Says:

    [...] Stop acting rich @ Joe [...]

  6. Monevator Says:

    I love that phrase about hyper-consumers. Like a lot of things such as sex, fun and being thin, it’s easy to get the impression from culture that ‘everyone is at it’ and you’re depriving yourself.

    Best to switch off the culture and live by your own rules. :)

  7. What is Cool Around the Web This Week : Real-Time Finance Says:

    [...] Stop acting rich @ Joe [...]

  8. David Wilson Says:

    Very good advice. A lot of people still don’t realize that by making small, simple changes in their habits, it will affect their financial status in the end.

  9. John Bensin Says:

    This post reminds me of Paul Fussell’s book “Class: A Guide Through the American Status System.” He talks about the people who *are* rich, e.g. Buffet, and the people who *act* rich but live well beyond their means. Of course, there is overlap, but Fussell also discusses how social perceptions reinforce concepts of wealth, especially “old wealth” vs. “new wealth”, and how its holders should behave.

  10. Joe Says:

    Looks like an interesting read, I’ll add to my ‘to read’ list, thanks!

Leave a Reply